The Institute for Accountability in Southern Africa

print document

Of Baboons and Men; passing the buck is offside (cont.)

The Institute for Accountability in Southern Africa (IFAISA), gets some interesting and unusual requests for assistance from time to time. The Simon’s Town resident who asked for an urgent meeting recently got the thinking caps out when he put the issues surrounding the clash between marauding baboons and human inhabitants/visitors to the Southern Peninsula on the table.

The problem is in essence one of competition for scarce resources. The baboons have, over time, learned that it is easier to feed the troop to which they belong in suburbia or at the road side from those conveniently parked tourist vehicles than it is to do so in the wild. Some troops are now permanently in or adjacent to the suburban areas at the edge of the Table Mountain National Park and there is regular friction between them and humans.

The City of Cape Town, the Table Mountain National Park (TMNP) personnel and Cape Nature have all applied their minds to the problems presented without actually coming up with a solution that is acceptable to all. A lively town hall meeting, the fundamental instrument of democracy, was held in Simon’s Town to ventilate the issues at stake. Before the meeting was held the new Premier of the Western Cape was communicated with by IFAISA in the following terms:

"Re: Baboon colonization of parts of the South Peninsula

The problems concerning the baboon colonization of parts of the suburban fringe in the South Peninsula will require urgent attention from your incoming provincial administration and the City, in conjunction with Table Mountain National Park. I have been requested by concerned citizens who live in Simon's Town to seek a pro-active and constructive solution to the problems posed by the invasion and "settlement" of suburbia by various baboon troops which roam the Southern Peninsula.

There is a difficulty with the attitude of TMNP, which, relying on outdated common law notions, seems to think that it is able to wash its hands of the problems of "theft", "robbery" and "trespassing" perpetrated by baboons who have become habituated to living in suburbia. TMNP is wrongly advised as it has a constitutional obligation to respect, protect, promote and fulfill the human rights of the people who happen to live adjacent to or near the Park. These rights include the right to property, privacy, dignity, life, bodily integrity, movement and to an environment which is not harmful to their health or well-being. In this regard I remind you, probably unnecessarily so, of the provisions of [ss 7(2), 10, 11, 12, 14, 21, 24 and 25] of the Bill of Rights. All of these rights are paramount and are guaranteed. The rights of children under [s 28] are of particular concern as their interests have to come first. There is a reasonable apprehension that it is only a matter of time before a child is seriously injured or killed by a marauding baboon. (A death in a baboon attack has already happened in the Northern Cape, so alarmism forms no part of this apprehension). The baboon troops that have colonized surburbia are increasingly bold and fearless in their interaction with humans in the neighbourhoods in which humans have attempted to deal with the invasion in a humane and non-confrontational manner. In those neighbourhoods in which baboons find their way into the pot, there is less friction as the baboons swiftly learn to stay clear of areas in which they are not tolerated.

The City and the provincial Cape Nature personnel are making a positive attempt to address the risks and dangers inherent in the situation which has developed as a result of the burgeoning and suburb-ward migration of the baboon population. Budget constraints, the unfortunate attitude of TMNP and a lack of clarity of understanding of the applicability of the constitutional obligations set out above are bedeviling progress and any possible solution to the problems of friction between baboon and human. There is a lack of appropriate, constitutionally compliant policy and rules in view of the relative novelty of the problem in the areas concerned.

There is a need for pro-active solution seeking, which may well necessitate the translocation or possible extermination of baboons who have taken up residence too close to suburbia.

There is a potential for vigilante action against baboons which would only complicate matters, bring the law in disrepute and serve to aggravate the problems that already exist by reason of baboons and humans sharing the same areas with the former plundering the latter. It would also be unfortunate, from a nature conservation perspective, should open warfare break out between frustrated and indignant humans and the invading baboons.

University of Cape Town’s (UCT's) Dr Justin O'Riain has conducted a scientific study with GPS monitoring of baboons that shows that some troops of baboons have in essence become suburbanites.

There are many people who are concerned to find a win-win solution, but time is short and solutions seem to be in shorter supply. Leadership is required, which is why I have been asked to write to you. If you need further detail, please do not hesitate to communicate with me and I shall take instructions so as to be of assistance, if at all possible."

After this letter was written the local daily press carried a photograph of a very silly tourist busily taking holiday snaps of a family of baboons at the side of the road. In order to get good close-ups for his album, the man concerned had left the safety of his car and seemed to be blithely unaware of the alpha male baboon, which was clearly visible in the background of the press photo, poised to pounce on him if he got any closer to the baboon family.

One hopes that the authorities will not wait for a tragedy to occur before taking appropriate steps to attend to the deleterious consequences of the clash between mankind and "baboondom". Passing the buck back and forth between the various spheres of government which have overlapping and competing responsibilities won’t do. It is necessary that reasonable and accountable steps be taken to address the problem. The sooner, the better.

At the time of going to press, no response to the letter to the Premier had been received.

Paul Hoffman
May 2009


<< Current Affairs